The Puerto Rican holiday table is not complete without something sweet, and a cold glass of coquito. I collected my favorite Puerto Rican holiday desserts here, plus the coconut nog that belongs next to them, so you can plan the sweets while the pernil or pavochon is in the oven.
Most of these can be made ahead, which is how I like to cook in November and December.
Flan for the Holidays
Flan de Calabaza (Puerto Rican Pumpkin Flan)
This flan de calabaza is creamy, caramel-topped, and full of pumpkin spice. Make it ahead for your Thanksgiving dessert table, and keep it in the rotation through Christmas.
Flan de Queso (Cheese Flan)
Flan de queso is a creamy cheese flan with a caramel top. It is one of the desserts I reach for when I want a classic Puerto Rican finish to a holiday meal.
Chocolate and Coffee Flancocho
Flancocho layers cake and flan in one dessert. This chocolate and coffee version is a fun one to bring out when you want something a little extra.
Chai Spiced Orange Flan with Cranberry Compote
This chai-spiced orange flan with cranberry compote has all the warm spice and color I want on a holiday dessert table.
Coconut Desserts
Arroz con Dulce (Coconut Rice Pudding)
Arroz con dulce is a traditional Puerto Rican holiday dessert made with rice, coconut milk, and spices. It is creamy and lightly sticky, and it can be made several days ahead.
Tembleque (Coconut Pudding)
Tembleque is a coconut pudding with a gentle jiggle and a lot of coconut flavor. It is one of my favorite Puerto Rican desserts to set out with the holiday sweets.
Coquito
Coquito (Puerto Rican Coconut Nog)
Christmas means it is time for coquito! This creamy Puerto Rican coconut rum drink is easy to make ahead, served ice-cold, and made without egg yolks.
Sweet Breads and Cookies
Mallorca Bread (Pan de Mallorca)
Mallorca bread is a plump, fluffy, buttery Puerto Rican sweet roll dusted with powdered sugar. Let the dough rise overnight in the fridge and serve the rolls with coffee on a holiday morning.
Mantecaditos con Guayaba (Shortbread Cookies with Guava)
Mantecaditos con guayaba are tender shortbread almond cookies with a little guava. They keep well on a cookie plate through the holidays.
Quesitos de Guayaba (Cream Cheese and Guava Pastries)
Quesitos are flaky pastries filled with sweetened cream cheese and guava. They are a bakery treat I love to make at home when I want something special with coffee.
Puerto Rican Holiday Desserts FAQ
What desserts are served at a Puerto Rican Christmas? Arroz con dulce, tembleque, and flan are the ones I see most, with coquito to drink. Mallorca and mantecaditos are lovely for Christmas morning or a dessert table.
Can I make these ahead? Yes. Flan is best after an overnight chill in the pan. Arroz con dulce can be made several days ahead and kept refrigerated. Coquito should be served ice-cold, so make it early and keep it in the fridge.
What should I serve with coquito? I like it with mallorca, flan, or a plate of cookies. For the rest of the holiday menu, see my Puerto Rican Christmas recipes and Puerto Rican recipe collection.









Leave a Reply